How do you comfort a Deaf mourner sitting shiva?
Many people hesitate to visit a Deaf mourner when they do not know the sign language the person uses. Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi explains that a quiet visit can fulfill the mitzvah of comforting mourners, as long as the mourner understands why the visitor has come. In that situation, simply showing up can mean a great deal.
Read how a quiet shiva visit can offer comfort when conversation is difficult.
When can a quiet visit fulfill the mitzvah?
A person wants to pay a shiva visit to a Deaf mourner but does not know the sign language the mourner uses. Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi explains that the mitzvah can be fulfilled through the visit itself, provided the mourner understands that the visitor came to offer comfort.
What Maimonides and the Talmud teach
Maimonides counts comforting mourners among the obligations established by the sages and places it under the commandment to love your neighbor as yourself.
These are acts of kindness one performs in person.
Rabbi Yohanan teaches that visitors wait for the mourner to open the conversation (Babylonian Talmud, Moed Katan 28b). Maimonides records the same rule (Laws of Mourning 13:3). Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi explains how a quiet visit can fulfill the mitzvah in the particular case of a Deaf mourner who understands why the visitor came.
What a quiet visit gives the mourner
Going to sit with someone acknowledges their loss and shows that they still have a place in the community. It offers company at a time when a person can feel isolated and lets them choose whether and how to engage. Even without a shared sign language, a visitor can show that the mourner and their grief matter.
Takeaway If the mourner understands that you came to offer comfort, a quiet visit can fulfill the mitzvah.
Questions and answers
Can a quiet shiva visit fulfill the mitzvah of comforting a Deaf mourner?
Yes. Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi explains that a quiet visit can fulfill the mitzvah as long as the mourner understands that you came to offer comfort.
Should I visit if I do not know the mourner’s sign language?
Yes. Rav Arusi encourages you to visit even if conversation is difficult. The act of showing up can offer meaningful support.
האם ביקור שקט אצל אדם חירש היושב שבעה מקיים את המצווה?
כן. לדברי הרב רצון ערוסי, גם בלי לדבר אפשר לקיים את מצוות ניחום האבלים, כל עוד האבל מבין שהמבקר בא לנחם אותו.
האם כדאי להגיע לשבעה בלי לדעת את שפת הסימנים של האבל?
כן. הרב ערוסי מעודד להגיע גם כשהמבקר אינו יודע איך לשוחח עם האבל. בנסיבות כאלה, לעצם ההגעה והבעת התמיכה יש משמעות מיוחדת.