Skip to main content
Why the Shabbat precedent is different

A troubling dream on Hanukkah: is a second fast required?

Why the Shabbat precedent is different

The lesson begins with the case of an exceptionally distressing dream on Shabbat. Rav Arusi explains that the exceptional fast then calls for a compensatory fast on a weekday. Shabbat ordinarily forbids fasting and also requires meals as part of its enjoyment.

Hanukkah also prohibits fasting, but does not require a set meal with bread. For that reason, Rav Arusi declines to extend the Shabbat rule to someone who already fasted on Hanukkah. He cautions against imposing another fast on oneself in that case.

Questions and answers

Is fasting ordinarily permitted on Hanukkah?

The ordinary rule discussed in the lesson prohibits fasting on Hanukkah.

If I already fasted because of a dream, do I make up for it with another fast?

According to Rav Arusi, no further fast should be taken in that case.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript