Skip to main content
The field tent and the empty apartment

Hanukkah on reserve duty: where can you light?

The field tent and the empty apartment

Rav Ratzon Arusi treats the basic obligation as one borne by a person in a dwelling. In the case described, the field tent does not qualify as a home and having someone light in the unoccupied apartment does not help. He follows a distinction drawn by Rav Moshe Feinstein (Igrot Moshe, Yoreh De’ah III, 14:5).

The lesson suggests asking in advance whether a break and a suitable place of lodging can be arranged at lighting time. It also considers a person who genuinely returns to the parents’ household for the relevant period and can be covered by its lighting.

Questions and answers

Does someone else’s lighting in my empty apartment count?

In the case discussed, the apartment is empty. Sending someone there does not fulfil the reservist’s obligation.

What arrangement does the lesson suggest?

Ask whether a break can be arranged at lighting time in a place that serves as a dwelling.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, who holds a doctorate in law and specializes in Jewish law.

Listen to the original lesson and read the Hebrew transcript