Skip to main content
The act of lighting and the place of a guest

What makes the lighting itself the Hanukkah mitzvah? Shabbat 22a–23a

The act of lighting and the place of a guest

Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok follows the Talmud’s argument that the act of lighting, in its proper setting, is central to the mitzvah.

The lesson returns to lighting one lamp from another, then reads the examples of lighting indoors and carrying the lamp out, and of rekindling an already burning lamp for the mitzvah. It closes with the Talmud’s discussion of a guest contributing to the oil and a traveller whose household lights at home.

Questions and answers

Why is placing an already lit lamp a separate issue?

The discussion asks whether the kindling itself took place as the mitzvah requires.

What practical question does the guest passage raise?

It asks how a guest takes part in the host’s light when no household lights on their behalf elsewhere.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript