Skip to main content
Where to add the day’s passage and what happens if it is omitted

Al Hanissim in Grace after Meals and Aneinu on a fast day

Where to add the day’s passage and what happens if it is omitted

Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok studies the Talmud’s discussion of adding Al Hanissim to Grace after Meals and traces different practices for the fast-day prayer Aneinu.

The Talmud places the Hanukkah addition in the blessing of thanksgiving. The lesson distinguishes the established practice of saying it from the obligation to repeat a blessing or prayer if it is omitted. It then compares customs that say Aneinu at several services with the practice of an individual saying it only at Mincha.

Questions and answers

Where does Al Hanissim go in Grace after Meals?

In the blessing of thanksgiving, as the lesson explains from Shabbat 24a.

Does forgetting Al Hanissim require repeating Grace after Meals?

According to the discussion, no.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript