Skip to main content
Relighting in the intended location

Can you move a burning menorah from the table to the doorway?

Relighting in the intended location

Rav Arusi teaches that when moving the menorah from an indoor table to its proper place at the entrance in this case, the lamps should first be put out.

The act of kindling is what fulfils the mitzvah. Carrying the burning lamps out and merely setting them down is not the correction. The lesson directs extinguishing, placing the menorah at the entrance and relighting there, without repeating the blessing in this doubtful case.

Questions and answers

Does carrying the lit menorah to the doorway suffice?

No, in the circumstances discussed. The lamps are relit at the intended place.

Is the blessing repeated?

The lesson does not require another blessing in this case of doubt.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript