Skip to main content
The duty to watch the Hanukkah lamp

When a Hanukkah lamp causes a fire, does the mitzvah affect liability?

The duty to watch the Hanukkah lamp

A branch overhanging the boundary of two properties caught fire from a Hanukkah lamp set inside one courtyard. The flame spread to the neighbour’s courtyard. Rav Ratzon Arusi starts with Maimonides’ case of a shopkeeper who sets out a lamp and causes damage. The shopkeeper is liable even when the lamp was for Hanukkah, because he should have stayed to watch it (Laws of Property Damage 14:13).

The general rule is that performing a mitzvah does not itself exempt a person from responsibility for damage. The lesson separates that principle from the question of the overhanging branches and what could reasonably have been done about them. Rav Arusi leaves that part of the case for the next lesson.

Questions and answers

Does a Hanukkah lamp have a general exemption?

No. Maimonides’ example expressly includes a Hanukkah lamp and refers to the duty to watch it.

Does this lesson decide the neighbour’s fire claim?

It establishes the general principle. The part of the case concerning the branches is treated separately.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, who holds a doctorate in law and specializes in Jewish law.

Listen to the original lesson and read the Hebrew transcript