Skip to main content
The courtyard gate and what passers-by can see

Where should you light if your home’s door does not face the street?

The courtyard gate and what passers-by can see

Rav Ratzon Arusi draws on Maimonides’ discussion of lights at home entrances and of a courtyard with two openings (Laws of Megillah and Hanukkah 4:10). If the house door is set back and the courtyard has a gate to the street, the gate better serves the purpose of making the miracle known.

When two entrances face different directions, the reason for a light at both is the impression of passers-by who see only one of them. The lesson distinguishes this concern from a separate public display and discusses the person’s own obligation at the place where they are staying.

Questions and answers

Should I prefer a gate that opens directly onto the street?

Yes, in the case discussed, if the house door itself is set back inside the courtyard.

Why can two openings call for lights on both sides?

People approaching from one side may see no light and assume no lighting took place.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript