Skip to main content
Enhancing the mitzvah within one’s means

May you add more Hanukkah lights than your family custom?

Enhancing the mitzvah within one’s means

The question concerns someone whose family adds one light each night for the whole home and who wishes to follow the enhancement described by Maimonides, counting the members of the household as well as the night. Rav Ratzon Arusi allows the change as a personal enhancement, provided it does not imply that the family’s practice was invalid.

He then distinguishes the recognised levels of enhancement from unlimited spending. The special importance of publicising the miracle does not justify spending beyond one’s means. He directs the person to stay within the forms of enhancement established by the sages and within what the household can afford.

Questions and answers

May I follow Maimonides’ enhanced lighting if my family uses a different custom?

Yes, in the case discussed, when the change is a personal choice to enhance the mitzvah and respects the family custom.

Is there a limit to spending on the additional lights?

Stay within the recognised forms of enhancement and what you can afford.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript