Skip to main content
The lighting, the blessing and the owner’s rights

What if someone lit Hanukkah candles taken without permission?

The lighting, the blessing and the owner’s rights

At a hotel, one group lit candles that had been set aside for another. Rav Ratzon Arusi asks whether ownership is a condition of the Hanukkah lighting. He contrasts it with the explicit ownership requirement for the lulav on the first day of Sukkot.

In the case of wrongfully taken candles or oil that were already lit, Rav Arusi concludes that the lighting obligation was fulfilled after the fact, but the taking was forbidden and no blessing should have been said over it. The owner is still owed what is due for what was consumed, and the unused property remains subject to return.

Questions and answers

Does lighting make taking someone else’s candles permissible?

No. The obligation to the owner remains, even though the lighting counts after the fact in this case.

Should a blessing be recited over candles deliberately taken without permission?

According to Rav Arusi in the case discussed, no.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript