Skip to main content
Wicks, oils and the purpose of the flame in Shabbat 21a

Why do the rules for Shabbat lamps and Hanukkah lamps differ?

Wicks, oils and the purpose of the flame in Shabbat 21a

Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok compares the Talmud’s discussions of wicks for the Temple and wicks and oils for Shabbat and Hanukkah.

A Shabbat lamp is meant to provide usable light, so a poorly burning wick might lead someone to adjust it. The Hanukkah discussion ties the use of those materials to the questions of whether one may use the light and whether a flame that goes out needs relighting.

Questions and answers

Why does the quality of a wick matter for a Shabbat lamp?

The lamp is used for illumination, and someone might adjust a flame that burns poorly.

Why can a Hanukkah lamp be different?

The passage considers limitations on using its light and whether it must be relit if it goes out.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript