Skip to main content
Direct lighting, an intermediate flame and the honour of the mitzvah

May one Hanukkah lamp light another? A study of Shabbat 22a

Direct lighting, an intermediate flame and the honour of the mitzvah

Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok studies the debate between Rav and Shmuel about transferring a flame between Hanukkah lamps.

The lesson relates the debate to the prohibition on counting coins by the lights and examines the difference between direct kindling and using an ordinary flame as an intermediary. It also notes why some customs are more cautious about lighting an additional lamp from the first one.

Questions and answers

Why distinguish direct kindling from an intermediary?

A transfer through an ordinary flame raises a separate concern about using the mitzvah lamp.

Do all customs follow the same practice?

No. The lesson discusses differing views on transfers and stricter customs.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript