Skip to main content
Why the ruling differs from candle lighting

Are women obligated to recite Hallel on Hanukkah?

Why the ruling differs from candle lighting

Rav Arusi reads Maimonides as obligating women in the Hanukkah lights while exempting them from the complete Hallel.

Maimonides expressly links lighting to the obligation to read the Megillah. Rav Arusi finds a different rule for Hallel, which he connects to the fixed framework of prayer. He points to Maimonides’ instruction that listeners repeat the words of a woman prompting Hallel to fulfil their own obligation.

Questions and answers

Are women obligated in Hanukkah lighting?

Yes. The lesson bases that obligation on Maimonides’ explicit comparison with the Megillah.

Why does the lesson reach a different conclusion about Hallel?

Rav Arusi understands full Hallel as part of the fixed prayer framework and applies the exemption he finds there.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript