Skip to main content
Sharing the oil before the lamp is lit

Does a guest’s contribution count if paid after lighting?

Sharing the oil before the lamp is lit

The case concerns a guest who has nobody lighting on their behalf at home and no separate entrance to their room. Ordinarily they take a share in the host’s oil, for instance by contributing a small coin, before the host lights (Maimonides, Laws of Megillah and Hanukkah 4:11).

If the guest did nothing to join until after the lighting, Rav Ratzon Arusi says the contribution does not ordinarily apply to the act already performed. If the lighting period has not ended, he discusses lighting a lamp to fulfil the obligation. A guest who explicitly agreed to contribute before lighting and only took out the coin afterward presents a different case. There, he relies on the more lenient view and does not require a new lighting.

Questions and answers

When should I arrange my share in the oil?

Arrange it before the host lights.

What if I said I was joining before lighting but paid after?

The lesson distinguishes that case and does not require a new lighting.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, who holds a doctorate in law and specializes in Jewish law.

Listen to the original lesson and read the Hebrew transcript