Skip to main content
The lighting blessings and a customary song

Can a child sing Hanerot Halalu during the Hanukkah lighting?

The lighting blessings and a customary song

Rav Ratzon Arusi considers a parent who says the blessings and lights the Hanukkah lamps while a child wants to sing Hanerot Halalu. The requirement for a person obligated in the lighting applies to the act and its blessings. The customary text is a separate part of the ceremony.

The lesson traces the text to Massekhet Soferim and discusses its later reception, including the Tur (Orach Chayim 676) and the Yemenite prayer book Etz Chayim. Maimonides describes the lighting blessings without prescribing Hanerot Halalu. A child may therefore lead the customary text in the family setting described.

Questions and answers

May the child sing while the parent is still lighting?

Yes. Rav Arusi encourages this in the family practice discussed.

Does the child’s singing replace the lighting blessings?

The person responsible for the lighting says the blessings. The child can lead the separate customary text.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, who holds a doctorate in law and specializes in Jewish law.

Listen to the original lesson and read the Hebrew transcript