Skip to main content
Two ways of remembering the miracles

Why Hanukkah lighting and Hallel carry different obligations

Two ways of remembering the miracles

In Maimonides’ ruling as taught here, women are obligated in lighting Hanukkah lamps. They are exempt from Hallel and may recite it without a blessing.

Rav Arusi proposes understanding the difference through two acts of remembrance: Hallel gives thanks for victory, while lighting recalls the Temple oil and the preservation of holiness. On Hanukkah an obligated person says full Hallel even when praying alone, unlike the communal custom for Rosh Chodesh.

Questions and answers

Are women obligated to light Hanukkah lamps?

Yes, the obligation to light applies to women as well as men.

May a woman recite Hallel on Hanukkah?

Yes, without a blessing under the approach taught here.

Adapted from a lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, a scholar of Jewish law.