Skip to main content
Hanukkah lights and responsibility for damage

Who is responsible if Hanukkah lights start a fire next door?

Hanukkah lights and responsibility for damage

A lamp stood inside its owner’s property. An ordinary gust moved the neighbour’s overhanging branches into the flames. Rav Ratzon Arusi recalls the principle from the previous lesson: fulfilling a mitzvah does not by itself discharge responsibility for damage.

The position of the branches and the possibility of removing the danger also matter. Would a timely request to the neighbour have resolved it? If speaking to the neighbour was impracticable, was another remedy available? These facts bear on how responsibility is assessed.

Questions and answers

Does lighting for a mitzvah exempt me from responsibility for damage?

Fulfilling the mitzvah does not in itself exempt the person who lit. The circumstances of the fire still matter.

Can the position of the branches matter?

A lamp stood inside its owner’s property. An ordinary gust moved the neighbour’s overhanging branches into the flames. Rav Ratzon Arusi recalls the principle from the previous lesson: fulfilling a mitzvah does not by itself discharge responsibility for damage.

About the source

An article based on the Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, who holds a doctorate in law and specializes in Jewish law.

Listen to the lesson and read the Hebrew transcript