Skip to main content
A public mitzvah and the duty to watch the flame

A Hanukkah lamp caused a fire: who bears responsibility?

A public mitzvah and the duty to watch the flame

A courtyard entrance facing a public way makes the Hanukkah lamp visible to passers-by. Rav Ratzon Arusi explains that if the lamp causes a fire in the circumstances discussed, the person who placed it there remains liable even though the placement serves the mitzvah.

The reason he draws from Maimonides is that a person can stay and watch the lamp. The lesson distinguishes permission to act from the separate duty to guard against foreseeable damage when taking that precaution is possible.

Questions and answers

Does lighting for a mitzvah provide an exemption from damages?

In the case taught, no. The duty to publicise the miracle goes together with a duty to watch the lamp.

Why does guarding the flame matter?

The risk to others can be addressed by remaining with the lamp. That ability is central to the explanation.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript