Skip to main content
Choosing a place that makes the lights visible

The door is hidden, the window faces the street: where should the Hanukkah lamp go?

Choosing a place that makes the lights visible

In the first case, a home’s door faces an area without passers-by and the courtyard gate faces the public way. Rav Ratzon Arusi gives preference to the courtyard gate. He considers Rashi’s emphasis on the house entrance and explains why he reads Maimonides as closer to the Tosafists’ approach to the gate of a courtyard.

The same consideration can favour a window facing the street when the door is secluded and the window is within the applicable height. Rav Arusi presents this as a preference for the place that better publicises the miracle. A person whose entrance has no passers-by and no better alternative can still light at the entrance.

Questions and answers

Where should the lamp go if only the courtyard gate faces the street?

In the case discussed, Rav Arusi gives preference to the courtyard gate.

What if a street-facing window is more visible than the doorway?

The lesson gives preference to the window when it meets the applicable conditions and makes the lights more visible.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript