Skip to main content
Distinguishing the lighting blessing from the blessings on seeing

The Hanukkah lights are already lit: which blessings can you still say?

Distinguishing the lighting blessing from the blessings on seeing

The blessing over the act of lighting is ordinarily said before the mitzvah is performed. Once the act is complete, it cannot simply be added afterward. Rav Ratzon Arusi treats She’asah Nissim, the blessing for the miracles, as a blessing connected to seeing the lights.

On the first night, he also permits Shehecheyanu in the case discussed while the prescribed period for seeing the lights is still in effect. He bases the distinction on the blessings available to someone who sees the lights. Shehecheyanu here is linked to the recurring mitzvah of Hanukkah lighting.

Questions and answers

Can I still say the blessing for the act of lighting?

The ordinary blessing over the act belongs before performing it. Once it is complete, that blessing is omitted.

Which blessings can still be said on the first night?

In the case discussed, Rav Arusi permits She’asah Nissim and Shehecheyanu within the prescribed period for seeing the lights.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript