Skip to main content
When one occasion is mentioned in a service prompted by another

Al Hanissim in Musaf and Rosh Chodesh in the haftarah blessing

When one occasion is mentioned in a service prompted by another

Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok follows Shabbat 24a from the Hanukkah addition in Musaf to the mention of Rosh Chodesh after the haftarah.

The lesson asks whether an occasion should be mentioned in all the day’s services or only where it independently requires that service. The haftarah case helps explain why customs differ about mentioning Rosh Chodesh in the blessing and in its conclusion.

Questions and answers

Why discuss Al Hanissim in Musaf?

Musaf exists that day because of Shabbat or Rosh Chodesh. The Talmud asks whether it nevertheless includes the Hanukkah addition.

Do customs agree about Rosh Chodesh in the haftarah blessing?

The lesson contrasts omitting it, mentioning it in the body, and mentioning it also in the conclusion.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript