Skip to main content
The place of the customary words in the lighting

Can a child sing Hanerot Halalu while an adult lights?

The place of the customary words in the lighting

The parent in the question recites the lighting blessings and lights the lamps. Rav Ratzon Arusi explains that Hanerot Halalu is a customary passage, recorded in Massekhet Soferim and not prescribed as one of the lighting blessings by Maimonides. The child can lead the customary words while the parent tends the lamps.

Communities differ about whether to begin the passage after the first light or after the whole lighting. The lesson describes the practice of saying it as the lighting proceeds. A child’s singing fits that practice and gives the child an active role.

Questions and answers

May a child sing the words rather than recite them?

Yes. In the arrangement discussed, the rabbi welcomes either form.

Does this change who recites the lighting blessings?

The adult still recites the blessings and lights. The child leads the separate customary passage.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript