Skip to main content
How daylight and the acceptance of Shabbat affect the answer

A Hanukkah light went out on Friday: when may you relight?

How daylight and the acceptance of Shabbat affect the answer

Maimonides rules that if a lamp was lit at the proper time with enough oil, a flame that later goes out need not be relit (Laws of Megillah and Hanukkah 4:5). The Shulchan Aruch applies that principle even when the Friday lamp goes out before Shabbat. Rav Arusi also discusses the view that relighting without a blessing is preferable while it is clearly daytime.

In Rav Arusi’s reading of Maimonides, a lamp lit well before sunset and extinguished while the sun is still up should be relit if Shabbat has not been accepted. Once sunset is too close to risk kindling on Shabbat, the lesson says to leave the lamp alone.

Questions and answers

Does the ordinary rule require relighting a lamp that has gone out?

A lamp lit at the proper time with enough oil need not be relit merely because it went out.

What makes Friday different?

Friday lighting is earlier. Rav Arusi distinguishes clear daylight before the acceptance of Shabbat from a time when kindling risks violating Shabbat.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript