Skip to main content
Lighting in the intended place

May a synagogue light the Hanukkah lamp low and then raise it?

Lighting in the intended place

Rav Ratzon Arusi starts with the household obligation. Maimonides explains that lighting inside and then placing the lit lamp at the doorway does not fulfil the obligation in the case discussed (Laws of Megillah and Hanukkah 4:9). Lighting must occur in the proper place. A slight move within the same place, for example to avoid people brushing against the lamp, is a different matter.

Synagogue lighting is a custom. The lesson notes opinions that are more lenient about moving the lamp there, especially within the same area. Rav Arusi’s advice is to light where the lamp is intended to stand from the start. This preserves the distinction between the act of lighting and placing an already lit lamp.

Questions and answers

What is preferable when the synagogue lamp stands high?

Arrange the lighting at the intended position from the start.

Is a slight adjustment always the same as moving the lamp to another place?

No. The lesson distinguishes a minor adjustment within the same place from lighting somewhere else and transferring the lamp.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, who holds a doctorate in law and specializes in Jewish law.

Listen to the original lesson and read the Hebrew transcript