Skip to main content
The shared entrance and each household’s obligation

Can one Hanukkah lamp paid for by the building cover all residents?

The shared entrance and each household’s obligation

Rav Arusi explains why contributing to one lamp through the residents’ committee does not fulfil the obligation of everyone in separate flats.

The residents share a lobby but have independent homes with their own doors. The lesson compares this with several households around a shared courtyard: individual lights can be placed near the same gate in the circumstances described. A communal display may help publicise the miracle but does not replace the lighting for each household.

Questions and answers

Does one lamp in the lobby cover separate flats if everyone contributes?

No, in the case discussed. Each household retains its own obligation.

Can several households light near the same entrance?

The lesson distinguishes separate household lights at the shared entrance from one light for all the flats.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript