Skip to main content
The obligation of the people who live in the home

Should a Hanukkah lamp be lit in a home empty all night?

The obligation of the people who live in the home

When nobody is at home at lighting time or will return that night, Rav Arusi explains that the empty home does not require a Hanukkah lamp.

The lesson distinguishes the obligation of a person in a dwelling from an obligation attached to the building. The concern about what passers-by see at two entrances applies to an occupied property. If someone nonetheless wishes a neighbour to light there, the lesson directs that there be no separate blessing for the empty home.

Questions and answers

Do I need to appoint someone to light if nobody will be home?

No, in the case discussed.

May that person say a separate blessing for the empty home?

Rav Arusi directs that no separate blessing be recited.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript