Skip to main content
The minimum obligation and a recognised way to beautify it

May you light fewer Hanukkah lamps each successive night?

The minimum obligation and a recognised way to beautify it

The Talmud (Shabbat 21b) records that Beit Shammai begins with eight and decreases, while Beit Hillel begins with one and increases. The reasons given include the days remaining or elapsed, the Sukkot offerings and the principle of increasing in holiness.

Rav Ratzon Arusi explains that the basic household obligation is one lamp each night. The question therefore concerns the accepted way of beautifying the mitzvah. In the practice he teaches today, a decreasing personal sequence does not convey the recognised meaning of the increasing lights and can confuse people who see them.

Questions and answers

Does a decreasing sequence fulfil the minimum obligation?

In the case discussed, the household’s basic obligation is met by one light each night. That question is distinct from whether the sequence counts as the accepted enhancement.

Which sequence does the lesson teach for current practice?

Begin with one and add a light each night, in accordance with the established practice of Beit Hillel.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.

Original lesson and Hebrew transcript