Completing both Torah readings with four aliyot
On a weekday when Rosh Chodesh falls during Hanukkah, the first three aliyot are read from the Rosh Chodesh passage and the fourth from the Hanukkah passage in a second scroll. Kaddish follows the fourth, so the four aliyot count together. The Talmud’s statement that Rosh Chodesh takes precedence refers, in the reading Rav Arusi follows, to which passage comes first.
If the fourth aliyah is still in progress, Rav Ratzon Arusi, explaining Maimonides, says that the same reader should read the Hanukkah passage in the second scroll, even if it has yet to be taken out. He distinguishes the Shulchan Aruch’s approach, which depends on whether the second scroll is already out. The lesson leaves open what to do if Kaddish has already been said.
Questions and answers
Who reads the Hanukkah passage if the fourth aliyah is still in progress?
According to Rav Arusi’s reading of Maimonides, the same person reads it in the second scroll.
What if Kaddish has already been said?
The lesson leaves that situation open and limits the solution above to an aliyah still in progress.
Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi.
Original lesson and Hebrew transcript