Completing Hallel and the order of Torah readings
A synagogue said the abbreviated Hallel of Rosh Chodesh and called four people to read only the Rosh Chodesh portion. Rav Ratzon Arusi says the full Hanukkah Hallel may still be recited later that day. Maimonides makes the day available for Hallel and requires the full text on each of the eight days (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Megillah and Hanukkah, chapter 3). If the congregation does not gather, individuals may recite it on their own with the blessings in the practice described.
On Rosh Chodesh during Hanukkah, the proper order is three readers from the first scroll for Rosh Chodesh and a fourth from the second scroll for Hanukkah. In this case four did read, so the basic Torah-reading duty was discharged even though the Hanukkah section was omitted. The rabbi distinguishes the full-day window for Hallel from the morning window for an ordinary morning Torah reading.
Questions and answers
Can I complete Hallel if my congregation does not?
Yes. In the practice described, an individual may recite full Hallel later that day with the blessings. The responsive format is for the congregation.
Which portion should the fourth reader read?
The fourth reader reads the Hanukkah portion from the second scroll. The first three read Rosh Chodesh from the first scroll.
Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rav Dr. Ratzon Arusi, who holds a doctorate in law and specializes in Jewish law.
Listen to the original lesson and read the Hebrew transcript