Skip to main content
A choice when money is scarce

Shabbat lights, Hanukkah lights or Kiddush: what takes priority?

A choice when money is scarce

The Talmud gives the household’s Shabbat lamp priority over a Hanukkah lamp or wine for Kiddush. Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok explains the concern for peace at home: a family sitting together in darkness lacks the benefit that the Shabbat light provides. Maimonides codifies that priority at the end of his Laws of Megillah and Hanukkah.

When the separate choice is between a Hanukkah lamp and wine for Kiddush, the Talmud gives the Hanukkah lamp priority because it publicises the miracle (Shabbat 23b). The choices show how the reasons for the practices affect their order when resources are limited.

Questions and answers

Why does the Shabbat light take precedence?

The Talmud gives priority to peace in the home, which the light makes possible.

What if the choice is only between a Hanukkah lamp and Kiddush wine?

In that case the Hanukkah lamp comes first because it publicises the miracle.

Based on a Hebrew lesson by Rabbi Elyakim Tzadok.

Listen to the original lesson and read the Hebrew transcript